shanima blogs

YouTube Ads vs. Instagram Ads: Where Should You Invest?

Shanima Sivadas A M's photo
Shanima Sivadas A M
·

4 min read

So, you’re ready to pour some money into ads, but you’re stuck between YouTube and Instagram. Both platforms have massive audiences, high engagement, and powerful targeting options. What's the best value for your money? Let’s break it down in simple terms so you can make the right choice for your business.

  1. Understanding the Audience

Before you even think about ad formats and budgets, you need to know who you’re targeting.

YouTube: Think long-form content lovers. YouTube is the second-largest search engine (after Google), and people come here to learn, be entertained, and dive deep into content. It’s great for businesses that need to explain their products in detail or create engaging storytelling.

Instagram: This platform thrives on quick, visually appealing content. People scroll fast, so your ad needs to grab attention in seconds. If your brand is highly visual—think fashion, beauty, fitness, or food—Instagram is a goldmine.

  1. Ad Formats: Which One Works Better?

Both platforms offer multiple ad formats, but let’s focus on the most popular ones:

YouTube Ads:

Skippable In-Stream Ads (appear before, during, or after a video; can be skipped after 5 seconds)

Non-Skippable Ads (15-20 seconds, must be watched before the video starts)

Bumper Ads (6-second, non-skippable ads—great for brand awareness)

Discovery Ads (appear in YouTube search results)

Instagram Ads:

Story Ads (full-screen vertical ads between stories)

Feed Ads (appear like regular posts in users’ feeds)

Reels Ads (immersive short videos within the Reels section)

Shopping Ads (directly linked to a product page)

If you’re all about storytelling and longer-form content, YouTube is the way to go. If you need quick, eye-catching visuals to drive impulse buys, Instagram wins.

  1. Cost Comparison: Where Do You Get More for Your Money?

Let’s talk numbers.

YouTube: The average cost per view (CPV) on YouTube ranges from $0.01 to $0.30, depending on targeting and ad type. You typically pay for views or impressions, and a “view” counts when someone watches at least 30 seconds or interacts with your ad.

Instagram: The average cost per click (CPC) on Instagram is $0.50 to $1.00. Since Instagram is owned by Meta (Facebook), it operates on an auction system, meaning costs vary based on demand and audience targeting.

If you’re looking for brand awareness and video engagement, YouTube is often cheaper. But if conversions and sales are your goal, Instagram’s higher engagement rates might be worth the extra cost.

  1. Targeting & Ad Performance: Which Platform Gives Better ROI?

Both platforms offer precise targeting based on demographics, interests, behaviors, and retargeting options. However, their strengths differ:

YouTube’s Strengths:

Leverages Google’s data for more detailed interest-based targeting

Great for retargeting users who have searched for related topics

Best for building brand authority and deep engagement

Instagram’s Strengths:

Higher engagement rates (people love scrolling and tapping on stories)

Great for impulse buys with seamless in-app shopping

Best for visually-driven products and brands

If you want to educate, entertain, or build authority—YouTube is the winner. If you want fast engagement and conversions, Instagram is your best bet.

  1. Which One is Better for Your Business?

Now, let’s match platforms to goals:

Go for YouTube Ads if:

You have a product or service that requires education (e.g., software, courses, complex products)

You want long-term brand awareness

You’re targeting people who search for solutions (e.g., “Best running shoes for beginners”)

Go for Instagram Ads if:

Your product is visually appealing (e.g., fashion, beauty, home decor, fitness)

You want quick conversions and impulse buys

Your audience is primarily younger (18-34 age group dominates Instagram)

Final Verdict: Where Should You Invest?

Honestly? It depends on your business and goals. If you’re running a brand awareness campaign, YouTube’s long-form content and cheaper views might be the best bet. But if you’re all about driving quick engagement and sales, Instagram’s high engagement rates can deliver faster results.

As the best freelance digital marketer in Kerala, I always recommend testing both! Run small ad campaigns on both platforms, analyze the performance, and double down on what works best for your brand. No matter where you invest, great content is what truly drives conversions. Happy advertising!

youtube